Alan's genuine and passionate devotion to
Equus and the sense that other characters, in contrast, are living unfulfilled
and unfulfilling lives.
Throughout the play, most characters
are depicted as having a belief in something; Dora in Christianity, Frank in socialism,
Dysart in the classically romantic world of Ancient Greece, and Alan in Equus.
However, Alan’s devotion to Equus is obviously the most passionate, to the
degree that he is characterized as insane by the society in which he lives.
This theme is significant because it makes the audience think about passion and
devotion and faith. Although Alan is worshipping a different deity he is doing
it with a fervour and intensity that makes our devotions seem pale and insipid
in comparison. This juxtaposition provokes reflection amongst the audience as
they are forced to reconsider their own beliefs and the value of what Dysart is
assigned to take away.
Ultimately, Shaffer appears to be implying
that people may have to give up the chance of living a fulfilling life in order
to conform to the expectations created by the society around them. An example
that highlights this is seen when Hesther visits Dysart and recalls up how
“[his] wife doesn’t understand [him].” and that she is, “mentally, always in
some drizzly kirk of her own inheriting,” suggesting that she is in her own
separate bubble of normality. This depressing description of the ‘drizzly kirk’
(and even Dysart’s feeble patting of his statue of Dionysus before he goes to
work) contrasts sharply with Alan’s more powerfully expressed faith in Equus,
for example where he is seen ‘sucking the sweat off of his god’s cheek.’
Page |
Quotation |
Explanation |
18 |
DYSART:
‘All reined up in old language and old assumptions, straining to jump… I can’t
see it, because my educated, average head is being held at the wrong angle. I
can’t ump because the bit forbids it… my horsepower, if you like – is too
little… The doubts have been there for years, piling up steadily in this
dreary place.’ |
The
words ‘reined up’ and ‘ straining’ suggest that Dysart is controlled and
limited, as if on a leash. Unlike Alan, he is not free, but is “controlled”
by his educated average head which conforms to society’s conception of the
“normal” so that there is no longer real passion This
is accentuated by the idea of his inadequate horsepower, suggests a lack of
fire, devotion, drive and the contrast with ‘dreary place’ suggests that
there is a lack of substance to Dysart’s life which is dry, shallow and as
seems to be devoice of interest and emotion. |
24 |
DYSART:
‘I’m officiating at some immensely important ritual sacrifice… the implied
doubt that this repetitive and smelly work is doing any social good at all…’ |
There
is a an irony here in that this supposedly immensely important ritual is
described as occurring at “some” place, which creates the impression that
there is a lack of interest or true commitment on Dysart’s part. In
addition, repetitive and smelly suggests that Dysart finds the work repugnant
and this contrasts to Alan’s midnight rituals where there is evident and
genuine personal investment. |
25 |
DYSART:
I feel the job is unworthy to fill me |
Once
again, this reinforces the sense that he finds his work unfulfilling and that
he lacks interest and passion which creates the sense that Dysart is just
doing a job rather than genuinely believing in the good of the work that he
does as a psychiatrist. In
particular the world ‘fill’ suggests he is not filled by his job creating an
image of emptiness which further emphasizes the theme of unfulfilling lives
of the other characters |
40 |
ALAN:
‘Bear me away! [Alan begins to laugh]… it’s lovely, dad!’ |
This
is one of the first times that the audience sees Alan’s passion and interest
in anything. The word ‘lovely’ creates the impression of youth, innocence and
purity suggesting Alan’s genuine passion and devotion. |
60 |
ALAN
(to Dysart): I bet you never touch her. Come on, tell me. You’ve got no kids,
have you? Is that because you don’t “F”? … DYSART:
Instead, she sits beside… and knits things for orphans in a home she helps
with. And I sit opposite, turning the pages of art books on Ancient Greece.
Occasionally, I still trail a faint scent of my enthusiasm across her path…
the familiar domestic monster… Do you know what it’s like for two people to
live in the same house as if they were in different parts of the world?... I
wish there was one person in my life I could show…’ |
Dysart
is a middle aged man who has no children and the fact that he hasn’t kissed
his wife for six years shows how empty, passionless and dull his life is.
Having sex with your husband / wife is perceived as being one of the biggest
symbols of passion, and the fact that it is missing in Dysart’s marriage and
his life, emphasizes that he is living a very unfulfilling life, especially
given the fact that Alan’s worship of Equus provides him with sexual as well
as spiritual fulfillment. This
is accentuated by the term ‘faint scent of enthusiasm’ which suggests that
there is barely anything left of this passion and that this action is more of
a routine than anything else, the complete opposite of what passion is
supposed to be Dysart’s
longing for company and someone that he can share his passion with further
reinforces the idea that he is trapped in his own world and that there is no
one to share his excitement. |
60 |
DYSART:
“They aim unswervingly at your area of maximum vulnerability... Which I
suppose is a good a way as any of describing Margaret.” |
This
quotation not only suggests Alan’s insight and manipulative skills (in some
ways he is more like Dysart than he may have originally seemed) but Dysart’s
reference to his wife as his ‘area of maximum vulnerability’ reinforces the
degree to which Dysart’s marriage is a frail shadow of the rewarding and
enjoyable relationship that it should be. |
61 |
DYSART:
“No, we didn’t go in for [children]. Instead, she sits beside our
salmon-pink, glazed brick fireplace, and knits things for orphans in a home
she helps with. And I sit opposite, turning the pages of art books on Ancient
Greece.” |
An
impression of Dysart’s own distaste for his relationship with his wife is
conveyed by this quotation. The implied sexual dullness suggested by the fact
that they did not have children is reinforced by Dysart’s depiction of what
seems to be their daily life, during which – despite being husband and wife –
they spend their time together sitting apart, each immersed in their own
hobbies, which are unimportant to the other. This
sense of distance between the two is accentuated through Dysart’s perspective
of his wife’s lifestyle. The depiction of the fireplace as salmon-pink and
glazed brick conveys the impression of a life that is solidly middle class
and the dull passivity implied is further emphasized by her knitting “things”
as knitting is, in itself, an unexciting, sedentary task and the sense of
distance between the two is accentuated by the fact that he has no interest
in the “things” which she is knitting, and therefore in what she does. In
addition, this normalcy contrasts with Dysart’s work, further implying the
disconnection in their relationship, as the only times when the audience
witness Dysart’s excitement are when he is confronted with the unusual. An
idea further emphasized by an intimacy with Hesther that is made obvious in
lines like ‘You’re really quite splendid’ and the self-parodying ‘My wife
doesn’t understand me, Your Honour’, a classic divorce-court line. However,
this ability to parody himself suggests a certain level of self-awareness in
Dysart’s description of his own passion as he sits opposite Margaret. It is
short and simplistic, indicating that despite his grand dreams, he still
realizes that to some extent, there is a lack of life in his passion, and
that he is not accomplishing anything through reading books on Ancient Greek
and gazing at artifacts – he is, in fact, just as unfulfilled as his wife. |
62 |
DYSART:
“I wish there was one person in my life I could show.” |
This
parallels Alan’s predicament, perhaps even the reason that he is in the
mental hospital to start with. At points Shaffer implies that Alan’s wants to
be ‘fixed’ so that he can accepted by society. Like everybody else, he craves
social acceptance and this quotation suggests that Dysart feels the same and
wants at least one person to agree with his passion, yet his wife puts it
aside and calls it nonsense. Less
sympathetically, this line can be read as Dysart using the fact that his wife
does not share his passion as an excuse for not living fully. However, as we
learn from Alan, true passion does not have to be shared or even understood
by others. In this way Alan’s ability to celebrate his faith even in the
absence of support from anyone else further reveals Dysart’s passiveness. |
62 |
DYSART:
“Mentally, she’s always in some drizzly kirk of her own inheriting: and I’m
some Doric Temple - clouds tearing through pillars - eagles bearing
prophecies out of the sky. She finds all that repulsive.” |
In
this description Dysart seems to be comparing his own fascination with the
world of Ancient Greece to Alan’s belief in Equus. The use of powerful
diction such as ‘tearing’ and epic imagery such as the eagles bearing
prophecies are used to imply that he is world is as passionate and vital as
Alan’s, especially in contrast to the mundanity of ‘drizzly kirk’. There
is a particularly interesting use of the word ‘inheriting’ which perhaps
echoes the way in which Alan (and all of us) have inherited our beliefs from
the world around us in some way or another. |
62 |
“exactly
like his mother. Utterly worshipless.” |
The
lifelessness of Dysart’s marriage is accentuated here. Ironically, Dysart is
accusing his wife of being “the familiar domestic monster” (61), while he
himself is equally as passive about his own passion for the life of Ancient
Greece. |
65 |
DYSART
“Parts sacred to rarer and more wonderful Gods. And at what length..” |
Here
again we see Dysart debating over whether or not it is right to ‘cure’ Alan
of his faith in Equus. “And at what length...” implies that Alan will have to
lose something that is of vital importance to him during this process of
normalization. This statement suggests not only that Alan has to give up his
God in order to fit, but also that all of us have to face a similar choice
between passion or belonging … no one can have both. |
65 |
DYSART:
“Normal is… the dead stare in a million adults. It both sustains and kills…
Sacrifices to the Normal can take as long as sixty months.” |
The
obvious claim that normality is lays out his conflict In the barest of forms:
normal (the rest of society) is dead because there is no passion, devotion,
faith or belief and so therefore, in contrast to Alan, all of the other
‘normal’ characters are not truly living life. The use of ‘a million adults’
implies commonality and a loss of individuality … as if we are just like
everyone else and, having lost our passion, we have lost the key thing that
distinguishes us from other people and marks us out as special. The idea that
‘the Normal’ is a destructive force is reinforced by the image of making
‘sacrifices’ which implies that something has to be lost / offered up to this
god in order to become accepted. |
74 |
ALAN:
“I want to BE you forever and ever!
– Equus, I love you! … [He lowers his head and kisses Nugget’s hoof. Finally
he flings back his head and cries up to him.] AMEN!” |
Shaffer
creates a stark contrast between Alan and the other relationships in the
play, most notably Dora and Frank’s and Dysart and Margaret’s. The
relationships that are most fulfilling are Dysart’s with Hesther and Alan’s
with Jill and none of these have the passion, the unfettered power and are as
free from restriction as Alan’s relationship with Equus. Diction such as
‘love’, ‘cries’ and ‘amen’ suggest an intensity of emotion and devotion …
conveying the way in which riding Nugget takes on the form of an ecstatic
religious experience for Alan. |
78 |
“DORA:
… Whatever’s happened has happened because of Alan … If you added up everything
we ever did to him … you wouldn’t find why he did this terrible thing –
because that’s him; not just all of our things added up … I only know he was
my little Alan, and then the Devil came.” |
Dora
is a contrast to Alan in the way that she is mostly portrayed as a fairly
passive character. While her husband takes control and Alan rides in the
mist, she is a softer presence behind the two men. Her
approach to religion itself is a contrast to Alan as she timidly prays to God
and hopes for the best while Alan engages in night-time rides and ritualistic
self-harm because of his complete devotion to his religion. Dora
seems to be leading an unfulfilling life in comparison because she displays a
sort of helplessness in the way she refuses to bear responsibility for Alan’s
actions and blames what he has become on the Devil, seemingly indicating that
despite her devotion to her own religion, events are out of her control. |
82 |
DYSART:
“But that boy has known a passion more ferocious than I have felt in any
second of my life… I envy it.” |
Shaffer’s
use of ‘ferocious’ here emphasizes the twinned nature of Alan’s desire: it is
both powerful and dangerous at the same time. In contrast, the simplicity of
Dysart’s statement ‘I envy it’ suggests that this is an undeniable truth to
him. |
82 |
“DYSART:
That’s the Accusation! … ‘At least I galloped! When did you?’ . . . [Simply.]
I’m jealous, Hesther. Jealous of Alan Strang.” |
As
above, this quotation depicts a moment of realization for Dysart, to which
all of the doubts triggered by his interactions with Alan have been leading.
Despite his professed love of Ancient Greece, Dysart is aware that in
comparison to Alan, his ‘passion’ is not worthy of the name. Alan only lives
one night every three weeks … but that is better than Dysart who doesn’t
appear to have lived once in at least six years. In
this way Alan can even be considered inspiring – and Dysart acknowledges
this. By admitting that he is jealous of Alan Strang. |
83 |
“DYSART:
I sit looking at pages of centaurs trampling the soil of Argos – and outside
my window he is trying to become one, in a Hampshire field! . . . I watch
that woman knitting, night after night – a woman I haven’t kissed in six
years – and he stands in the dark for an hour, sucking the sweat off his
God’s hairy cheek! [Pause.] Then in the morning, I put away my books on the
cultural shelf, close up the kodachrome snaps of Mount Olympus, touch my
reproduction statue of Dionysus for luck – and go off to hospital to treat
him for insanity. Do you see?” |
This
quotation is a reflection of Dysart’s internal conflict which appears to be
reaching a crisis point as the extremes to which Alan goes for his religion
evoke a kind of envy in him. He wonders whether the sort of passion that can
make a young man more alive than Dysart himself has ever been is something
which he should be taking away, especially when most of society remains
docile and lives what, in comparison, seems to be a dull and unfulfilled
life. The
contrast between his own actions and Alan’s actions best illustrate this. For
example, Dysart describes himself as simply sitting, and looking at pages of
centaurs trampling the soil of Argos – a fairly passive activity that
requires imagination and appreciation from the mind, but which, for all of
the mind’s vividness, remains a dream that will slip away once the book is
closed and reality calls again. Those
are spikes of momentary passion limited by societal perceptions as centaurs
are confined to roam in only dreams. However Alan shatters this convention by
trying to “become one” in a Hampshire field. The contrast between the dreams
never fulfilled, and Alan’s complete devotion to his religion emphasizes the
idea that in comparison to Alan, other characters’ lives seem unfulfilled.
The contrast between “the soil of Argos” and “a Hampshire field” also
accentuates how Alan’s passion is the one making his ideals a reality as the
location seems to be unimportant to him. This also contrasts with Dysart’s more
pallid dreams of Ancient Greece and the fact that Dysart has to be in the
actual place in order to fill alive implies his lack of imagination. Furthermore,
Dysart’s comparison of his sexual life (or lack of thereof) with Alan’s
intimate contact with his God further emphasizes how Alan displays much
greater passion than ‘most men’. Dysart’s description of his own morning
ritual where he ‘touch[es]’ his statue for luck simultaneously conveys to the
reader the sense that Dysart’s devotions are much less exciting and much less
involved than Alan’s. Once again this suggests that Alan’s greater passion
makes Dysart’s own life (and the lives of the audience members) seem
unfulfilled as our rituals seem tame and less vital in comparison. |
90 |
“JILL:
Girls [find horses sexy]. I mean, they go through a period when they pat them
and kiss them a lot. I know I did. I suppose it’s just a substitute, really.” |
This
line may be read as suggesting that even children appear to be living
unfulfilled lives as Jill asserts young girls often go through a period of
pseudo-sexual intimacy with horses presumably before transferring these urges
to other more ‘normal’ objects of affection. This clearly mirrors the way in
which Alan’s sexual urges and desire for intimacy has become conflated with
the riding of horses and the line actually suggests that this ‘abnormal’
behaviour may be just an extension of ideas and behaviours that we see in the
world around us all the time. Jill
is an interesting character because it is unclear how fulfilling her life is.
On the one hand she seems to be the only character who is comfortable and
confident in her sexuality. The fact that she seems to regularly visit “skin
flicks”– judging them all (not just this one) as “silly” – and the fact that
she seems quite sexually experienced, seducing Alan and then noting that his
temporary impotence is not uncommon, suggests that she has a normal and happy
sexual life. However,
we assume that this is not the first time that Jill has seduced a boy and
perhaps the implied repetition suggests an emptiness to her actions. In
addition the sex, although it may be enjoyable seems not to be particularly
meaningful, and so perhaps we can see her as just mechanically embracing the
sexual permissiveness of the 1970s and so therefore just as much a product of
her inheritance as Margaret is of hers. |
97 |
“ALAN
[to DYSART]: Sorry. I mean for him. Poor old sod, that’s what I felt – he’s
just like me! He hates ladies and gents just like me! Posh things – and
la-di-da. He goes off by himself at night, and does his own secret thing
which no one’ll know about, just like me! There’s no difference – he’s just
the same as me – just the same! –” |
In
this quotation following Alan’s discovery that his father regularly visits
the cinema to watch pornography we realize that Frank too lives an
unfulfilling life and Alan’s sympathy for him is one of the things that helps
us to sympathise with both Frank and Alan. Ultimately, the play does not seem
to point the finger of blame at Alan’s parents for being overly repressive …
instead it simply charts the development of a personality, the ways in which
it can go ‘awry’ and the ways in which abnormal personalities are so close to
normal ones that perhaps the line separating them isn’t as significant as we
think it is. The
episode with Frank has obvious parallels with Alan’s own ‘unacceptable’ way
of achieving sexual gratification although Alan’s method is fully committed,
and despite being also secret, there is more reverence than shame. As a
result his ‘deviant sexuality’ may seem quite grand while in contrast,
Frank’s visits to the cinema seem more tawdry and pathetic, as suggested by
his nervous glances around. Thus in comparison to Alan’s full devotion to his
nightly excursions, Frank’s form of compensation seems unfulfilling. |
108 |
“Passion,
you see, can be destroyed by a doctor. It cannot be created.” |
This
line reinforces the doubts Dysart has about his profession and suggests the
value of the passion that it is his task to destroy. |
109 |
“DYSART:
… There is now, in my mouth, this sharp chain. And it never comes out. [A long pause. DYSART sits
staring.]” |
This
quotation encapsulates the fact that in comparison to the freedom Alan enjoys
in his complete worship of Equus the other characters, and especially Dysart
who has experienced increased self-awareness throughout the play, are living
unfulfilled and unfulfilling lives. This is can be clearly seen in the
imposition of the “Normal” which, along with common conceptions of what
counts as acceptable behaviour, are the chains controlling Dysart and holding
his head at the wrong angle. There is a sense of resignation and defeat in
the way it never comes out and in his final stare before the black out and
this ends the play on a somber note, as Dysart concludes that he cannot
change society’s expectations and finally paints a picture of himself as just
another horse controlled by the world in which he lives. One
final point worth considering, however, is the question of whether or not
Alan is really free. His worship of Equus seems grand and powerful, but to
what degree is it just reining him in using a different set of rules? |